Third Culture Kids: An Alternative Answer to “Where are You From”?

by | Sep 7, 2019 | Blog | 2 comments

How do you feel about the question, “Where are you from?” My own brain immediately starts to spin at the question – spiralling through all the variables that could be relevant to the questioner…

Place or country?

Where I was born or where I have spend the most time? 

The country that they can see in my face/accent/language, or the one I feel most attached to?

But also… why is the person asking? Did break a social rule that betrayed me as not being from ‘here’? Are they trying to figure out if we are alike? Are they trying to figure out which cultural box I belong in, and what to expect from me?

So what do we answer?

Often we scramble an answer based on what we think the questioner needs – something that won’t completely confuse their expectations of us. At other times, we evade with a vague, “Lots of places” or “Nowhere” (!) Occasionally, when we feel our questioner is really interested, we might go into the details, include more variables. But it’s rarely the whole story, and we can feel strangely at odds with the answer we have given – as though we have betrayed the unmentioned places, and people.

In conversation the other day, an alternative response was born. We were exploring how we often stop short of laying claim to countries and cultures where we lack citizenship or ethic roots. Noting this, I queried why we deny ourselves these links to belonging. It can feel like appropriation, a kind of cheap theft of others’ stories to say “I come from…” places that we can’t ‘officially’ claim as ours. Appropriation hurts. And we don’t need to do it to communicate our own stories. We can’t “borrow” from others’ stories and expect our own to sound coherent.

So the alternative?

We don’t need to tell people where we are from, which implies a singular origin. Instead, we tell people where we grew.

For so many of us Place is the problematic. And Place can also be the solution.

So an alternative answer to “Where are you from?” is “I am from the soil that grew me”

Okay, so it sounds kooky when put like that but bear with me. We talk of feeling rootless when we could talk of being multi-rooted. The trouble is for many of us that our energies in childhood went into growing roots quickly in many new places, rather than growing one more deeply.

But we can nurture depth in our multiple roots – by acknowledging the soil in which they are growing, and investing in it.

Strengthening our roots

For myself, I was grown in several soils – Nigerien, French, English and American (plus mission organisation culture/soil). I can acknowledge the elements of these cultures that seeped into making me me, without laying claim to ownership of these cultures. I can trace back the elements of me that were grown in all these cultures – my sense of humour, gestures, values, accent(s), favourite recipes and cultural references. These were grown in multiple soils. Soil that grew me.

Even if we don’t want to answer the “Where are you from?” question with “I grew in Nigerien, French, English, American and mission ‘soil'” (!) we can hold the concept in mind while we construct an answer that communicates our rootedness in multiple places. This can take soul-searching and a lot of creativity – but it’s worth it. With this investment in our story’s roots, we can we can confidently acknowledge where we are rooted, and continue to nurture those roots.

Do you want to explore your roots and strengthen your story? Do you want to feel more confident in communicating where you are from? Get in touch here today – I can help you deepen your connection to the places of your story and clarify your sense of self.

 

2 Comments

2 Comments

  1. Dan Elyea

    Often a problematic question indeed, Dr. Rachel. As you put in different words, the context often can help frame our response. For a shortie, I might say, “I graduated from high school in Michigan, but I’ve lived most of my life in Florida (over 40 years).” Mentioning Nigeria and Liberia brings on complications that I may or may not want to engage. The full schmeer would go something like, “I’ve lived in Chicago twice; in Michigan twice, in North Carolina twice; in Massachusetts; in Florida; in Nigeria twice; and in Liberia,” TMI for sure! Our tendency to hesitate before answering the question may well signal the one making the query that there’s more here than meets the ear. Some years ago I wrote an essay on a similar question: Where is home? But I haven’t tackled “Where are you from?” yet. 🙂 Thank you for sharing your insights.

    Dan

    Reply
    • Dr. Rachel Cason

      Yes! It’s a constant struggle against TMI! 🙂 Where is home is another good question for sure too… Thank you for reading!

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More from my blog

Third Culture Kids and Adverse Childhood Experiences

Third Culture Kids and Adverse Childhood Experiences

I knew it’d be hard to read Tanya Crossman and Lauren Wells’ recent research. I was right. As much as I eagerly read the methodologies and results of their work, “Caution and Hope: The Prevalence of Adverse Childhood Experiences in Globally Mobile Third Culture Kids”, I could feel a heart clench of pain for the many TCKs I work with who know the pain of adverse childhood experiences all too well.

read more
Third Culture Kids and Repatriating Well

Third Culture Kids and Repatriating Well

A client shared with me recently how they had been looking for accounts of Third Culture Kids repatriating, and how little they had found to very little to inform them. This challenged me in more ways than one – first to consider why the narrative of TCK repatriation...

read more
The Third Culture Kid drive to “be good”

The Third Culture Kid drive to “be good”

I’m currently sat at my desk in a mild slumpy grumpy space. It’s because I’ve eaten too much sugar, and drunk too much coffee and now I feel I need a good long lie down. I want to hide from myself, because I’m cross that I over-indulged. However, given that I’m me, I’m feeling curious as well as grumpy – why did I do it? Why did I eat and drink more than was good for me? Now I’m getting all philosophical and asking the BIG question – why do we do what we don’t want to do, and why don’t we do what we want?

read more